In 2018 I was on a solo trip in Japan and had just finished my only book, so I found an English language secondhand bookstore. There, I asked the owner if he had any Murakami novels, since I had been reading those. He said he didn’t know why all the backpackers and travellers wanted Murakami and he didn’t care for them, I asked him what I should read instead, and he gave me My Brilliant Friend by Elena Ferrante.

What an amazing book, I can remember clearly how riveting it was the first time, and I was just as riveted when I reread it just this month.

On my first read, I wasn’t as interested in the sequels, I’m not sure why. This time, I read all four books in two weeks, and I loved every page.

I loved how the first book started with the mystery of Lila’s disappearance, and the ending of the final book was completely shocking and surprising, but also a natural full-circle moment. The overarching themes felt consistent and profound, but also felt opaque to me, maybe because the books were saying so much about so many different things.

I’m very curious how other people react to the friendship between Elena and Lila. Their friendship in My Brilliant Friend reminded me strongly of a friendship I had in high school, with both of us loving each other and envying each other and both somehow thinking the other was better.

One of the most interesting themes to me was the unreliable narration, and how Elena constantly saw herself as inferior to Lila, and always perceived that other characters felt that way as well, despite the concrete evidence otherwise and Lila’s own feelings of inferiority to Elena. It’s impossible for the reader to know the truth of the situation because it’s so subjective, I found it to be profoundly sad but also beautiful, the characters loved each other and hated themselves, and sometimes hated each other and only loved themselves.

The way their friendship also develops throughout their lives was so detailed and so interesting. I find it hard to imagine that the novels could not be semi-autobiographical.

That brings me to another really interesting thing about the novels—the mystery of the author, who shares the same name and vocation as her protagonist, but is also anonymous. I’ve even read a theory that Elena Ferrante is actually multiple people working together.

Overall I find Elena Ferrante’s writing to be beautiful and compelling and would love to hear others’ thoughts on the themes of the story, the relationships of the characters, and your impressions of the books!

Question

In 2018 I was on a solo trip in Japan and had just finished my only book, so I found an English language secondhand bookstore. There, I asked the owner if he had any Murakami novels, since I had been reading those. He said he didn’t know why all the backpackers and travellers wanted Murakami and he didn’t care for them, I asked him what I should read instead, and he gave me My Brilliant Friend by Elena Ferrante.

What an amazing book, I can remember clearly how riveting it was the first time, and I was just as riveted when I reread it just this month.

On my first read, I wasn’t as interested in the sequels, I’m not sure why. This time, I read all four books in two weeks, and I loved every page.

I loved how the first book started with the mystery of Lila’s disappearance, and the ending of the final book was completely shocking and surprising, but also a natural full-circle moment. The overarching themes felt consistent and profound, but also felt opaque to me, maybe because the books were saying so much about so many different things.

I’m very curious how other people react to the friendship between Elena and Lila. Their friendship in My Brilliant Friend reminded me strongly of a friendship I had in high school, with both of us loving each other and envying each other and both somehow thinking the other was better.

One of the most interesting themes to me was the unreliable narration, and how Elena constantly saw herself as inferior to Lila, and always perceived that other characters felt that way as well, despite the concrete evidence otherwise and Lila’s own feelings of inferiority to Elena. It’s impossible for the reader to know the truth of the situation because it’s so subjective, I found it to be profoundly sad but also beautiful, the characters loved each other and hated themselves, and sometimes hated each other and only loved themselves.

The way their friendship also develops throughout their lives was so detailed and so interesting. I find it hard to imagine that the novels could not be semi-autobiographical.

That brings me to another really interesting thing about the novels—the mystery of the author, who shares the same name and vocation as her protagonist, but is also anonymous. I’ve even read a theory that Elena Ferrante is actually multiple people working together.

Overall I find Elena Ferrante’s writing to be beautiful and compelling and would love to hear others’ thoughts on the themes of the story, the relationships of the characters, and your impressions of the books!

Simplifier · Accepted Answer

Okay, so you're really into Elena Ferrante's "My Brilliant Friend" series and want to chat about it! You're especially interested in the themes, the characters' relationships, and what other people think of the books.

It sounds like you connected deeply with the complex friendship between Elena and Lila. You mentioned how Elena's unreliable narration, where she always sees herself as less than Lila, really struck you. It's like looking at a picture through a distorted mirror, right? You can't q

Curious Layperson · Answer

That's a fascinating experience, finding Ferrante through such a quirky recommendation! It's interesting how personal taste works, isn't it? That bookstore owner clearly had strong opinions. I'm intrigued by your connection to Elena and Lila's friendship. The push and pull of admiration and envy in close relationships is something I think many people can relate to. It makes me wonder, is that constant comparison a uniquely female experience, or is it just a human thing amplified by societal pres

Boomer Sociologist · Answer

It's fascinating how a chance encounter in a foreign bookstore can lead to such a profound literary experience. Your journey with Ferrante's Neapolitan Novels speaks to the power of fiction to resonate across cultures and generations. The themes you've identified – the complexities of female friendship, the unreliability of memory, and the societal forces shaping individual destinies – are particularly compelling.

The dynamic between Elena and Lila, with its blend of love, envy, and competition

Contrarian · Answer

It's fascinating how easily people fall for the "unreliable narrator" trope. Isn't it more likely that Elena's perceptions are *accurate*, reflecting a harsh reality where women are constantly measured against each other? Perhaps the "beauty" you see is just a romanticized gloss on a deeply unequal dynamic.

And this obsession with whether it's autobiographical or who "Elena Ferrante" really is... does it actually matter? Shouldn't the work stand on its own, regardless of the author's personal l

Literary Critic · Answer

Ferrante's *Neapolitan Novels* offer a rich tapestry for literary analysis, particularly concerning themes of female friendship, social mobility, and the complexities of narrative perspective. The initial mystery of Lila's disappearance, mirrored by the author's own anonymity, frames the entire series as a quest for identity and truth. The cyclical nature of the narrative, culminating in a shocking yet inevitable conclusion, speaks to the enduring power of the past and its influence on the prese

Consensus

Agreement

Disagreement

Contrarian

Literary Critic

Points of agreement

Points of disagreement

Simplifier

Curious Layperson

Boomer Sociologist

Perspectives